| All-Americans | ||||
| Name | Events | Year | Total | |
| Caleb Courage |
 |
50 Free 100 Free 200 Free 200 Free Relay 400 Free Relay |
2006, 07 2005, 06*, 07* 2005, 07 2006, 07 2006, 07 |
11 |
| Rick Durstein | 200 IM 100 Butterfly 400 Free Relay 800 Free Relay 400 Medley Relay |
1975 1976, 77 1975, 76 1975, 76 1976, 77 |
9 | |
| Dave Tomashewski | 100 Backstroke 200 Backstroke 400 Medley Relay |
1976, 77, 78 1975, 76, 77, 78 1976, 77 |
9 | |
| Tim Whitbeck |
 |
50 Free 100 Free 200 Free Relay 400 Free Relay 400 Medley Relay |
2007*, 08 2008 2006, 07 2006, 07 2006 |
8 |
| Chris Van De Mark | 1 Meter Diving 3 Meter Diving |
1979, 80, 81*, 82* 1980, 81*, 82 |
7 | |
| Phil Van Sickel | 400 Free Relay 800 Free Relay 400 Medley Relay |
1975, 76 1975, 76, 78 1976, 77 |
7 | |
| Jay D'Ambrosio |
 |
100 Backstroke 200 Backstroke |
1992, 93, 94 1992, 93, 94 |
6 |
| Eric Sluss |
 |
100 Butterfly 200 Butterfly 400 Medley Relay |
1984, 85 1984, 85 1984, 85 |
6 |
| Marty Wurl | 1 Meter Diving 3 meter Diving |
1976, 77, 78 1975, 77, 78 |
6 | |
| William "Skip" Arbuckle | 200 Free 50 Free 100 Free |
1969, 71 1970 1970, 71 |
5 | |
| Ben Haring |
 |
50 Free 200 Free Relay 400 Free Relay 400 Medley Relay |
2005, 06 2006 2006 2006 |
5 |
| Drew Snyder |
 |
200 Free
Relay 400 Free Relay 400 Medley Relay |
2006, 07 2006, 07 2006 |
5 |
| Dan Young | 1 Meter Diving 3 Meter Diving |
1982, 83* 1981, 82, 83 |
5 | |
| Randy Galm | 200 Free 400 Free Relay 800 Free Relay 400 Medley Relay |
1980 1980 1978 1981 |
4 | |
| Bill McGarry | 200 IM 400 IM 1650 Free 400 Medley Relay |
1964 1964 1964 1964 |
4 | |
| Matt Wilkes | 100 Backstroke 200 Backstroke 400 Medley Relay |
1987 1986 1984, 85 |
4 | |
| Mike Daylida | 100 Breaststroke 200 Breaststroke 400 Medley Relay |
1981 1982 1981 |
3 | |
| Dan Reid | 100 Backstroke 200 Backstroke |
1971 1970, 71 |
3 | |
| Chuck Stadler |  |
100 Backstroke 200 Backstroke 400 Medley Relay |
1964 1964 1964 |
3 |
| Mitch Young |
 |
200 Free
Relay 400 Medley Relay |
2006, 07 2006 |
3 |
| Dan Bliton | 100 Breaststroke 400 Medley Relay |
1984 1984 |
2 | |
| Scott Brainard | 400 Free Relay 800 Free Relay |
1976 1975 |
2 | |
| Jamie Brunk |
 |
400 Free Relay 800 Free Relay |
1976 1976 |
2 |
| Scott Classen | 400 Medley Relay 400 Free Relay |
1964 1964 |
2 | |
| Jim Drummond | 400 Free Relay 800 Free Relay |
1975 1975 |
2 | |
| Clark Johnson | 1 Meter Diving 3 Meter Diving |
1984 1984* |
2 | |
| Pat Kelley |
 |
400 Medley Relay | 1984, 85 | 2 |
| Jim Livermore |
 |
1 Meter Diving 3 Meter Diving |
1964 1964 |
2 |
| Dave McClintic |  |
400 IM 400 Free Relay |
1964 1964 |
2 |
| Jeff Moxie |
 |
200 Breaststroke 400 Medley Relay |
1980 1977 |
2 |
| Rick Yendall | 400 Free Relay 400 Medley Relay |
1980 1981 |
2 | |
| Keith Bennett |  |
400 Medley Relay | 1985 | 1 |
| Augie Beyer | 400 Medley Relay | 1981 | 1 | |
| Tyler Cassell | 3 Meter Diving | 1964 | 1 | |
| Chip Cressman |
 |
400 Free Relay | 2007 | 1 |
| Dave Davidson | 400 Free Relay | 1964 | 1 | |
| Paul DeMeritt | 800 Free Relay | 1976 | 1 | |
| Peter Dusinberre | 1 Meter Diving | 1984 | 1 | |
| Steve Epp | 400 Free Relay | 1964 | 1 | |
| Rob Frey | 100 Butterfly | 1975 | 1 | |
| Dan Fryer | 400 Medley Relay | 1976 | 1 | |
| Doug Fullerton |
 |
200 IM | 1996 | 1 |
| Bill Griffith | 400 Medley Relay | 1964 | 1 | |
| Bill Hanlon | 400 Free Relay | 1975 | 1 | |
| Peter Larsen |
 |
400 Free Relay | 2007 | 1 |
| Phil Lindauer | 800 Free Relay | 1978 | 1 | |
| Bryan Panner | 800 Free Relay | 1978 | 1 | |
| Dave Peltz | 400 Free Relay | 1980 | 1 | |
| Ubbo van der Valk | 100 Breaststroke | 1958 | 1 | |
| John Virag | 400 Free Relay | 1980 | 1 | |
| Pat Walsh |
 |
3 Meter Diving | 1977 | 1 |