| Event | Name | Time | Site | Year |
| 50 Free | Tim Whitbeck | 20.19 |
NCAA Miami, OH |
2008 |
| 100 Free | Caleb Courage | 44.36 |
NCAA Houston, TX |
2007 |
| 200 Free | Caleb Courage | 1:40.33 | Grove City | 2006 |
| 500 Free | Chip Cressman | 4:40.83 | Grove City | 2007 |
| 1000 Free | Chip Cressman | 9:54.02 | Grove City | 2007 |
| 1650 Free | Chip Cressman | 16:20.41 | Grove City | 2007 |
| 100 Fly | Peter Larsen | 50.64 | Grove City | 2008 |
| 200 Fly | Eric Sluss | 1:54.87 | NCAA Atlanta, GA |
1984 |
| 100 Back | Jay D'Ambrosio | 52.04 | Grove City | 1994 |
| 200 Back | Jay D'Ambrosio | 1:53.63 | NCAA Buffalo, NY |
1992 |
| 100 Breast | Andrew Gilbert | 58.29 | Grove City | 2007 |
| 200 Breast | Doug Fullerton | 2:08.48 | Grove City | 1997 |
| 200 IM | Doug Fullerton | 1:55.34 | Grove City | 1997 |
| 400 IM | Doug Fullerton | 4:07.99 | Grove City | 1997 |
| 200 Free Relay |
Tim Whitbeck, Drew Snyder Ben Haring, Caleb Courage |
1:21.99 |
NCAA Minneapolis, MN |
2006 |
| 400 Free Relay |
Tim Whitbeck,
Peter Larsen Chip Cressman, Caleb Courage |
3:04.68 |
NCAA Houston, TX |
2007 |
| 800 Free Relay |
Chip Cressman, Drew Snyder Mark Barron, Caleb Courage |
6:55.76 | Grove City | 2007 |
| 200 Medley Relay |
Caleb Courage, Andrew Gilbert Peter Larsen, Tim Whitbeck |
1:33.21 |
NCAA Houston, TX |
2007 |
| 400 Medley Relay |
Caleb Courage, Andrew Gilbert Peter Larsen, Tim Whitbeck |
3:26.92 | Grove City | 2007 |
| 1 Meter Diving | Dan Young | 483.00 | Cleveland State | 1982 |
| 3 Meter Diving | Chris Van De Mark | 498.65 | Cleveland State | 1982 |
| Current Team Member |