Presidents'
Athletic Conference
| Event | Name | Time | School | Year |
| 50 Free | Orstein | 23.49 | W&J | 2008 |
| 100 Free | Angela Palumbo | 50.93 | Grove City | 2013 |
| 200 Free | Angela Palumbo | 1:51.00 | Grove City | 2013 |
| 500 Free | Dressler | 5:02.09 | Westminster | 2010 |
| 1000 Free | Megan Bilko | 10:29.27 | Grove City | 2013 |
| 1650 Free | Megan Bilko | 17:20.59 | Grove City | 2013 |
| 100 Fly | Kait Riesmeyer | 56.03 | Grove City | 2011 |
| 200 Fly | Peggy Whitbeck | 2:01.84 | Grove City | 2003 |
| 100 Back | Rambish | 57.42 | Westminster | 2009 |
| 200 Back | Mier | 2:05.09 | Westminster | 2009 |
| 100 Breast | Orstein | 1:02.04 | W&J | 2008 |
| 200 Breast | Lehberger | 2:15.86 | Westminster | 2012 |
| 200 IM | Orstein | 2:00.27 | W&J | 2008 |
| 400 IM | Orstein | 4:24.34 | W&J | 2007 |
| 200 Free Relay |
Jenny Ryan, Tori Baker Kait Riesmeyer, Angela Palumbo |
1:34.81 | Grove City | 2013 |
| 400 Free Relay |
Jenny Ryan, Jenna Richert Sarah Page, Angela Palumbo |
3:25.78 | Grove City | 2011 |
| 800 Free Relay |
Jenny Ryan, Megan Bilko Kait Riesmeyer, Angela Palumbo |
7:28.76 | Grove City | 2013 |
| 200 Medley Relay | Jenny Ryan,
Angela Palumbo Kait Riesmeyer, Sarah Page |
1:46.12 | Grove City | 2011 |
| 400 Medley Relay | Rambish,
Lehberger Mier, Dressler |
3:51.37 | Westminster | 2009 |
| 1 Meter Diving | Haver | 430.20 | W&J | 2010 |
| 3 Meter Diving | Haver | 443.55 | W&J | 2012 |