| 2nd Period Play-by-Play |
| | Start of 2nd period [45:00]. |
| [46:50] | Shot by SVC Daniel Moore, SAVE Caleb Koch. |
| | Foul on Saint Vincent. |
| | Corner kick by GRO Kyle Richert [57:28]. |
| [58:07] | Shot by SVC Daniel Moore, SAVE Caleb Koch. |
| | Foul on Saint Vincent. |
| [60:40] | Shot by SVC Brody Ruffner BLOCKED. |
| | Foul on Grove City. |
| [61:50] | Shot by SVC Gage Arnold BLOCKED. |
| [62:11] | SVC substitution: Michael Cerchione for Clemente Mejia. |
| | For GRO: #0 Caleb Koch, #17 Richie Kocur, #36 Nick Finelli, #6 Josh Kern, #13 Jesse Wilson, #10 Adam Brewer, #19 Brian Eckenhoff, #15 Mike Shupp, #31 Brian Wilkes, #32 Kyle Matherne, #12 Daniel Adams. |
| | Corner kick by GRO Kyle Matherne [63:15]. |
| [63:28] | Shot by GRO Daniel Adams WIDE LEFT. |
| [63:33] | SVC substitution: John DeSantis for Daniel Moore. |
| [66:12] | Shot by GRO Mike Shupp HIGH. |
| [66:15] | GRO substitution: Tim Boswell for Mike Shupp. |
| [66:25] | GRO substitution: Mark Leach for Daniel Adams. |
| | Corner kick by GRO Richie Kocur [67:27]. |
| [68:21] | GOAL by GRO Zach Juergens. |
| Grove City 2, Saint Vincent 0 |
| | *Shot from 20 yards out |
| [70:23] | Shot by GRO Adam Brewer, SAVE Jake Gilbertson. |
| [70:32] | SVC substitution: Connor Rohrback for Drake Pastor. |
| | Corner kick by GRO Kyle Matherne [71:12]. |
| [71:22] | Shot by GRO Zach Juergens HIGH. |
| | Foul on Saint Vincent. |
| [73:09] | Shot by GRO Richie Kocur WIDE. |
| [73:46] | GRO substitution: Eric Fitchwell for Richie Kocur. |
| | Foul on Saint Vincent. |
| [74:57] | Shot by GRO Tim Boswell, SAVE Jake Gilbertson. |
| [75:24] | Shot by GRO Tim Boswell WIDE LEFT. |
| [75:37] | SVC substitution: Elom Pedanou for John DeSantis. |
| [75:37] | SVC substitution: Daniel Moore for Michael Cerchione. |
| | Corner kick by GRO Eric Fitchwell [76:48]. |
| | Foul on Grove City. |
| | Foul on Saint Vincent. |
| [79:15] | Shot by GRO Tim Boswell WIDE RIGHT. |
| | Corner kick by GRO Eric Fitchwell [79:32]. |
| [79:46] | GRO substitution: Andrew Quinn for Brian Eckenhoff. |
| [79:55] | Header Shot by GRO Adam Brewer WIDE RIGHT. |
| [81:14] | GRO substitution: Andrew Wiley for Nick Finelli. |
| [81:14] | GRO substitution: George DeAugustino for Kyle Matherne. |
| [81:14] | GRO substitution: Jordan Carmichael for Josh Kern. |
| | Foul on Grove City. |
| [85:11] | Header GOAL by SVC Brody Ruffner, Assist by Gage Arnold. |
| Grove City 2, Saint Vincent 1 |
| | *Free kick from 40 yards out, headed in. |
| [85:17] | GRO substitution: Brian Eckenhoff for Zach Juergens. |
| [85:41] | Shot by SVC Trevor Cutlip WIDE LEFT. |
| | Corner kick by SVC Gage Arnold [86:00]. |
| [86:42] | GRO substitution: Richie Kocur for Jordan Carmichael. |
| | Corner kick by GRO Richie Kocur [86:49]. |
| [87:48] | Shot by GRO Adam Brewer BLOCKED. |
| [88:37] | Shot by SVC Brody Ruffner, SAVE Caleb Koch. |
| [89:13] | Shot by SVC Dean Jordan, SAVE Caleb Koch. |
| [89:20] | Shot by SVC John DeSantis HIT CROSSBAR. |
| | Foul on Saint Vincent. |
| | End of period [90:00]. |